Сжать supplier-overlap ответы и detector utility gap

2026-06-03 12:52:44 +03:00 · 2026-06-03 12:52:44 +03:00 · ed44c6428a
parent fdd04abbde
commit ed44c6428a
6 changed files with 109 additions and 49 deletions
--- a/docs/orchestration/detector_registry.json
+++ b/docs/orchestration/detector_registry.json
@ -134,7 +134,7 @@
      "kind": "answer_text_shape",
      "automation_level": "semi_automatic",
      "description": "The first meaningful line is not a direct business answer for a direct user question.",
-      "issue_codes": ["business_direct_answer_missing"],
+      "issue_codes": ["business_direct_answer_missing", "business_utility_gap"],
      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
      "check": {
        "first_line_should_be": "business_answer_or_honest_boundary"
@ -144,7 +144,7 @@
      "kind": "answer_text_regex_forbidden_in_prefix",
      "automation_level": "automatic",
      "description": "Answer starts with scaffold/service narration before the user-facing business conclusion.",
-      "issue_codes": ["business_direct_answer_missing"],
+      "issue_codes": ["business_direct_answer_missing", "business_utility_gap"],
      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
      "check": {
        "prefix_line_count": 3,
@ -155,7 +155,7 @@
      "kind": "answer_text_regex_forbidden",
      "automation_level": "automatic",
      "description": "Final user-facing answer contains runtime/debug/service tokens.",
-      "issue_codes": ["technical_garbage_in_answer"],
+      "issue_codes": ["technical_garbage_in_answer", "business_utility_gap"],
      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
      "check": {
        "forbidden_patterns": ["(?i)(route_id|capability_id|runtime_|snapshot_items|debug|answer_object|selected_object)"]
@ -165,7 +165,7 @@
      "kind": "answer_text_regex_forbidden",
      "automation_level": "automatic",
      "description": "Final user-facing answer contains capability ids or route ids.",
-      "issue_codes": ["technical_garbage_in_answer"],
+      "issue_codes": ["technical_garbage_in_answer", "business_utility_gap"],
      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
      "check": {
        "forbidden_patterns": ["(?i)(capability[_ -]?id|route[_ -]?id|address\\.[a-z0-9_\\.]+)"]
@ -185,13 +185,23 @@
      "kind": "answer_text_required_when_limited",
      "automation_level": "semi_automatic",
      "description": "Answer states a limitation but gives no concrete next action for recovering or narrowing the answer.",
-      "issue_codes": ["business_next_step_missing"],
+      "issue_codes": ["business_next_step_missing", "business_utility_gap"],
      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
      "check": {
        "limited_patterns": ["(?i)(не могу|не хватает|не подтвержден|нет данных|недостаточно)"],
        "required_next_action_patterns_any": ["(?i)(можно|следующ|уточн|перезапусти|проверь|выбери|нужен|добавь)"]
      }
    },
+    "business_answer_too_verbose_output": {
+      "kind": "answer_text_regex_forbidden",
+      "automation_level": "automatic",
+      "description": "A scoped business follow-up answer still exposes verbose proof/scaffold sections that should be collapsed into a compact proof line.",
+      "issue_codes": ["business_utility_gap", "business_answer_too_verbose"],
+      "inputs": ["steps/<step_id>/output.md"],
+      "check": {
+        "forbidden_patterns": ["(?im)^\\s*(Что проверили|Опорные документы):"]
+      }
+    },
    "route_candidate_needs_enablement": {
      "kind": "stage_review_signal",
      "automation_level": "semi_automatic",
--- a/docs/orchestration/issue_catalog.json
+++ b/docs/orchestration/issue_catalog.json
@ -237,6 +237,48 @@
        ]
      }
    },
+    "business_utility_gap": {
+      "severity": "P2",
+      "business_meaning": "Ответ технически заземлен, но для узкого бизнес follow-up остается слишком тяжелым или недостаточно практичным.",
+      "root_layers": ["answer_surface", "business_utility"],
+      "expected_answer_contract": "compact_business_followup_surface_v1",
+      "detectors": [
+        "business_answer_too_verbose_output",
+        "top_level_scaffold_before_answer",
+        "runtime_tokens_in_user_answer",
+        "capability_ids_in_user_answer",
+        "limited_answer_without_next_action"
+      ],
+      "allowed_patch_targets": [
+        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/address_runtime/composeStage.ts",
+        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/address_runtime/inventoryReplyBuilders.ts",
+        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/assistantMcpDiscoveryResponseCandidate.ts",
+        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/assistantService.ts"
+      ],
+      "forbidden_patch_targets": [
+        "route masking",
+        "fake evidence",
+        "evidence deletion from artifacts"
+      ],
+      "rerun_matrix": [
+        "failed_scenario",
+        "answer_surface_pack",
+        "accepted_smoke_pack"
+      ],
+      "acceptance": {
+        "must_have": [
+          "direct_answer_first",
+          "compact_business_surface",
+          "short_evidence_basis",
+          "honest_limitation_when_needed"
+        ],
+        "must_not_have": [
+          "verbose proof packet by default",
+          "technical ids",
+          "duplicated answer blocks"
+        ]
+      }
+    },
    "route_candidate_enablement_gap": {
      "severity": "P1",
      "business_meaning": "Планировщик понял бизнес-запрос, но route candidate ещё не исполняется как точная возможность.",
@ -427,7 +469,7 @@
      "severity": "P1",
      "business_meaning": "Ответ слишком длинный для прямого бизнес-вопроса и снижает практическую полезность.",
      "root_layers": ["answer_surface", "business_utility"],
-      "detectors": ["business_answer_too_verbose_signal"],
+      "detectors": ["business_answer_too_verbose_output", "business_answer_too_verbose_signal"],
      "allowed_patch_targets": [
        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/address_runtime/composeStage.ts",
        "llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/assistantMcpDiscoveryResponseCandidate.ts",
--- a/llm_normalizer/backend/dist/services/address_runtime/inventoryReplyBuilders.js
+++ b/llm_normalizer/backend/dist/services/address_runtime/inventoryReplyBuilders.js
@ -543,7 +543,7 @@ function composeInventoryReply(intent, rows, options, deps) {
        if (supplierScopedItemQuestion) {
            const requestedSupplierLabel = summary.counterparties[0] ?? String(options.counterpartyHint ?? "").trim();
            const directAnswerLine = supplierScopedItems.length > 0
-                ? `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} подтверждены позиции: ${inventoryItemLeadList(supplierScopedItems)}.`
+                ? `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} подтверждено позиций: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(supplierScopedItems.length)}.`
                : `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} позиции не подтверждены в доступном закупочном следе.`;
            const lines = [directAnswerLine];
            if (supplierScopedItems.length > 0) {
@ -552,24 +552,11 @@ function composeInventoryReply(intent, rows, options, deps) {
                    lines.push(`- Показаны первые 8 из ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(supplierScopedItems.length)} позиций.`);
                }
            }
-            (0, inventoryReplyPresentation_1.appendInventoryBulletSection)(lines, "Что проверили:", [
-                `Дата среза: ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)}.`,
-                `Период найденного закупочного следа: ${purchasePeriodLabel}.`,
-                `Закупочных документов / операций в выборке: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(summary.documents.length)} / ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)}.`
-            ]);
-            (0, inventoryReplyPresentation_1.appendInventoryBulletSection)(lines, "Ограничения:", [
-                "Без партионного учета этот ответ показывает закупочный след текущего остатка, но не доказывает владельца каждой конкретной партии.",
-                INVENTORY_SUPPLIER_ATTRIBUTION_NEXT_ACTION
-            ]);
+            lines.push("", `Проверка: срез ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)}; закупочный след ${purchasePeriodLabel}; документов/операций: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(summary.documents.length)} / ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)}.`);
            if (observedCounterparties.length > 0) {
-                lines.push(`- Найденные поставщики: ${inventoryPartyLeadList(observedCounterparties)}.`);
-            }
-            if (purchaseRows.length > 0) {
-                (0, inventoryReplyPresentation_1.appendInventorySection)(lines, "Опорные документы:", deps.formatInventoryTraceRows(purchaseRows, INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT));
-                if (purchaseRows.length > INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT) {
-                    lines.push(`- Показаны первые ${INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT} из ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)} найденных строк; полный след остается в подтвержденном срезе.`);
-                }
+                lines.push(`Поставщик в найденном следе: ${inventoryPartyLeadList(observedCounterparties)}.`);
            }
+            lines.push("Ограничение: без партионного учета это закупочный след остатка, а не доказательство владельца каждой конкретной партии.", INVENTORY_SUPPLIER_ATTRIBUTION_NEXT_ACTION);
            return (0, replyContracts_1.buildFactualSummaryReply)(lines, (0, replyContracts_1.buildConfirmedBalanceSemantics)(purchaseRows.length > 0 ? (supplierScopedItems.length > 0 ? "strong" : "medium") : "medium", purchaseRows.length > 0));
        }
        const directAnswerLine = observedCounterparties.length === 1
--- a/llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/address_runtime/inventoryReplyBuilders.ts
+++ b/llm_normalizer/backend/src/services/address_runtime/inventoryReplyBuilders.ts
@ -747,7 +747,7 @@ export function composeInventoryReply(
      const requestedSupplierLabel = summary.counterparties[0] ?? String(options.counterpartyHint ?? "").trim();
      const directAnswerLine =
        supplierScopedItems.length > 0
-          ? `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} подтверждены позиции: ${inventoryItemLeadList(supplierScopedItems)}.`
+          ? `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} подтверждено позиций: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(supplierScopedItems.length)}.`
          : `По поставщику ${requestedSupplierLabel} в складском срезе ${warehouseLabel} на ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)} позиции не подтверждены в доступном закупочном следе.`;
      const lines: string[] = [directAnswerLine];
      if (supplierScopedItems.length > 0) {
@ -760,30 +760,17 @@ export function composeInventoryReply(
          lines.push(`- Показаны первые 8 из ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(supplierScopedItems.length)} позиций.`);
        }
      }
-      appendInventoryBulletSection(lines, "Что проверили:", [
-        `Дата среза: ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)}.`,
-        `Период найденного закупочного следа: ${purchasePeriodLabel}.`,
-        `Закупочных документов / операций в выборке: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(summary.documents.length)} / ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)}.`
-      ]);
-      appendInventoryBulletSection(lines, "Ограничения:", [
-        "Без партионного учета этот ответ показывает закупочный след текущего остатка, но не доказывает владельца каждой конкретной партии.",
-        INVENTORY_SUPPLIER_ATTRIBUTION_NEXT_ACTION
-      ]);
+      lines.push(
+        "",
+        `Проверка: срез ${deps.formatDateRu(asOfDate)}; закупочный след ${purchasePeriodLabel}; документов/операций: ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(summary.documents.length)} / ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)}.`
+      );
      if (observedCounterparties.length > 0) {
-        lines.push(`- Найденные поставщики: ${inventoryPartyLeadList(observedCounterparties)}.`);
-      }
-      if (purchaseRows.length > 0) {
-        appendInventorySection(
-          lines,
-          "Опорные документы:",
-          deps.formatInventoryTraceRows(purchaseRows, INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT)
-        );
-        if (purchaseRows.length > INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT) {
-          lines.push(
-            `- Показаны первые ${INVENTORY_TRACE_EVIDENCE_ROW_LIMIT} из ${deps.formatNumberWithDots(purchaseRows.length)} найденных строк; полный след остается в подтвержденном срезе.`
-          );
-        }
+        lines.push(`Поставщик в найденном следе: ${inventoryPartyLeadList(observedCounterparties)}.`);
      }
+      lines.push(
+        "Ограничение: без партионного учета это закупочный след остатка, а не доказательство владельца каждой конкретной партии.",
+        INVENTORY_SUPPLIER_ATTRIBUTION_NEXT_ACTION
+      );
      return buildFactualSummaryReply(
        lines,
        buildConfirmedBalanceSemantics(
--- a/llm_normalizer/backend/tests/addressQueryRuntimeM23.test.ts
+++ b/llm_normalizer/backend/tests/addressQueryRuntimeM23.test.ts
@ -6308,11 +6308,18 @@ it("routes old purchase residue questions to aging-by-purchase-date", () => {
    );

    const firstLine = reply.text.split("\n")[0] ?? "";
-    expect(firstLine).toContain("подтверждены позиции");
-    expect(firstLine).toContain("Столешница 600*3050*26 альмандин");
-    expect(firstLine).toContain("Столешница 600*3050*26 дуб ниагара");
+    expect(firstLine).toContain("подтверждено позиций: 2");
    expect(firstLine).not.toContain("выявлен поставщик закупочного следа");
    expect(reply.text).toContain("Позиции:");
+    expect(reply.text.indexOf("Позиции:")).toBeLessThan(reply.text.indexOf("Проверка:"));
+    expect(reply.text).toContain("Столешница 600*3050*26 альмандин");
+    expect(reply.text).toContain("Столешница 600*3050*26 дуб ниагара");
+    expect(reply.text).toContain("Проверка:");
+    expect(reply.text).toContain("Ограничение:");
+    expect(reply.text).toContain("Следующий шаг:");
+    expect(reply.text).not.toContain("Что проверили:");
+    expect(reply.text).not.toContain("Опорные документы:");
+    expect(reply.text).not.toContain("Поступление товаров и услуг");
  });

  it("routes inventory provenance questions to a dedicated intent", () => {
--- a/scripts/test_domain_case_loop_lead_handoff.py
+++ b/scripts/test_domain_case_loop_lead_handoff.py
@ -211,6 +211,33 @@ class DomainCaseLoopLeadHandoffTests(unittest.TestCase):
        self.assertIn("first_line_not_direct_answer", detector_names)
        self.assertNotIn("runtime_tokens_in_user_answer", detector_names)

+    def test_business_utility_gap_uses_known_surface_detectors(self) -> None:
+        candidates = dcl.build_detector_candidates(
+            {
+                "target_count": 1,
+                "acceptance_status": "partial",
+                "final_status": "partial",
+                "targets": [
+                    {
+                        "target_id": "inventory_supplier_overlap:step_04_supplier_items_on_stock",
+                        "issue_code": "business_utility_gap",
+                        "severity": "P2",
+                        "evidence_paths": [
+                            "artifacts/domain_runs/pack/scenarios/inventory_supplier_overlap/steps/step_04_supplier_items_on_stock/output.md"
+                        ],
+                    }
+                ],
+            }
+        )
+
+        detector_names = [item["detector"] for item in candidates["candidates"]]
+
+        self.assertIn("business_answer_too_verbose_output", detector_names)
+        self.assertIn("top_level_scaffold_before_answer", detector_names)
+        self.assertIn("runtime_tokens_in_user_answer", detector_names)
+        self.assertIn("limited_answer_without_next_action", detector_names)
+        self.assertNotIn("business_utility_gap_detector", detector_names)
+
    def test_detector_results_gate_allows_pass_and_blocks_fail_or_review(self) -> None:
        pass_ok, pass_reason = dcl.evaluate_detector_results_gate({"status": "pass"})
        fail_ok, fail_reason = dcl.evaluate_detector_results_gate(