Files
NODEDC_1C/llm_normalizer/backend/tests/assistantWave6ProblemFirstAnswerContract.test.ts
T

320 lines
12 KiB
TypeScript

import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
import { composeAssistantAnswer } from "../src/services/answerComposer";
import type { AnswerGroundingCheck, RequirementCoverageReport, UnifiedRetrievalResult } from "../src/types/assistant";
import type { ProblemUnit } from "../src/types/stage2ProblemUnits";
function buildRouteSummary() {
return {
mode: "deterministic_v2" as const,
message_in_scope: true,
scope_confidence: "high" as const,
planner: {
total_fragments: 1,
in_scope_fragments: 1,
out_of_scope_fragments: 0,
discarded_fragments: 0,
contains_multiple_tasks: false
},
decisions: [],
fallback: {
type: "none" as const,
message: null
}
};
}
function buildCoverage(partial = true): RequirementCoverageReport {
return {
requirements_total: 1,
requirements_covered: partial ? 0 : 1,
requirements_uncovered: partial ? ["R1"] : [],
requirements_partially_covered: partial ? ["R1"] : [],
clarification_needed_for: [],
out_of_scope_requirements: []
};
}
function buildGrounding(status: AnswerGroundingCheck["status"] = "partial"): AnswerGroundingCheck {
return {
status,
route_subject_match: true,
missing_requirements: status === "partial" ? ["R1"] : [],
reasons: status === "partial" ? ["Coverage is partial for problem-first answer contract."] : [],
why_included_summary: [],
selection_reason_summary: []
};
}
function buildProblemUnit(input: {
id: string;
type: ProblemUnit["problem_unit_type"];
defect: string;
account: string;
lifecycleDomain?: ProblemUnit["lifecycle_domain"];
}): ProblemUnit {
return {
schema_version: "problem_unit_v0_1",
problem_unit_id: input.id,
problem_unit_type: input.type,
title: "Problem unit",
mechanism_summary: `Mechanism candidate: ${input.defect}.`,
business_defect_class: input.defect,
severity: {
score: 0.76,
grade: "high"
},
confidence: {
score: 0.52,
grade: "medium"
},
affected_entities: ["Document:DOC-1", "Posting:POST-1"],
affected_documents: ["Document:DOC-1"],
affected_postings: ["Posting:POST-1"],
affected_accounts: [input.account],
affected_counterparties: ["Counterparty:CP-1"],
affected_contracts: ["Contract:CTR-1"],
failed_expected_edge: input.defect,
period_impact: {
is_period_sensitive: true,
impact_class: "close_risk"
},
evidence_pack: ["cand-1"],
entity_backlinks: [{ entity: "Document", id: "DOC-1" }],
snapshot_limitations: [],
...(input.lifecycleDomain
? {
lifecycle_domain: input.lifecycleDomain
}
: {})
};
}
function buildRetrieval(units: ProblemUnit[], extras?: Partial<UnifiedRetrievalResult>): UnifiedRetrievalResult {
return {
fragment_id: "F1",
requirement_ids: ["R1"],
route: "hybrid_store_plus_live",
status: "ok",
result_type: "chain",
items: [
{
source_entity: "Document",
source_id: "DOC-1",
counterparty_id: "CP-1"
}
],
summary: {
broad_query_detected: true,
broad_result_flag: true,
minimum_evidence_failed: false,
degraded_to: "partial",
narrowing_strength: "weak",
semantic_profile: {
domain_scope: ["bank_settlement"],
account_scope: ["60"],
relation_patterns: ["payment_to_settlement"]
}
},
evidence: [
{
evidence_id: "ev-1",
claim_ref: "requirement:R1",
source_type: "retrieval_item",
source_ref: {
schema_version: "evidence_source_ref_v1",
namespace: "snapshot_2020",
entity: "document",
id: "DOC-1",
period: "2020-06",
canonical_ref: "evidence_source_ref_v1|snapshot_2020|document|doc-1|2020-06"
},
pointer: {
fragment_id: "F1",
route: "hybrid_store_plus_live",
source: {
namespace: "snapshot_2020",
entity: "document",
id: "DOC-1",
period: "2020-06"
},
locator: {
field_path: "risk_score",
item_index: 0
}
},
evidence_kind: "mechanism_link",
mechanism_note: "failed_edge:payment_to_settlement",
confidence: "medium",
limitation: {
reason_code: "weak_source_mapping",
note: null
},
payload: {
risk_score: 4
}
}
],
problem_units: units,
problem_unit_summary: {
schema_version: "problem_unit_summary_v0_1",
units_total: units.length,
duplicate_collapses: 0,
unit_types: units.map((unit) => unit.problem_unit_type),
type_distribution: {
[units[0]?.problem_unit_type ?? "broken_chain_segment"]: units.length
},
severity_distribution: {
low: 0,
medium: 0,
high: units.length
},
confidence_distribution: {
low: 0,
medium: units.length,
high: 0
},
primary_unit_type: units[0]?.problem_unit_type ?? null
},
why_included: ["semantic retrieval profile", "route=hybrid_store_plus_live"],
selection_reason: ["domain_scope + relation_patterns + route profile"],
risk_factors: ["broken_chain", "closure_risk"],
business_interpretation: ["problem-first signal"],
confidence: "medium",
limitations: ["Evidence is snapshot-only and may lag source-of-record."],
errors: [],
...extras
};
}
function composeCase(userMessage: string, retrieval: UnifiedRetrievalResult) {
return composeAssistantAnswer({
userMessage,
routeSummary: buildRouteSummary(),
retrievalResults: [retrieval],
requirements: [
{
requirement_id: "R1",
source_fragment_id: "F1",
requirement_text: "Проверить проблемный механизм",
subject_tokens: ["chain"],
status: "covered",
route: "hybrid_store_plus_live"
}
],
coverageReport: buildCoverage(true),
groundingCheck: buildGrounding("partial"),
enableAnswerPolicyV11: true,
enableProblemCentricAnswerV1: true,
enableLifecycleAnswerV1: true
});
}
function extractSection(text: string, title: string): string {
const escaped = title.replace(/[.*+?^${}()|[\]\\]/g, "\\$&");
const stopTitles = [
"Коротко",
"Что сломано",
"Почему это похоже на проблему",
"На чем это основано",
"Что проверить первым",
"Ограничения"
];
const stopPattern = stopTitles.map((item) => item.replace(/[.*+?^${}()|[\]\\]/g, "\\$&")).join("|");
const re = new RegExp(`${escaped}:([\\s\\S]*?)(?=(?:${stopPattern}):|$)`, "i");
const match = String(text ?? "").match(re);
return match?.[1]?.trim() ?? "";
}
describe("assistant wave6 problem-first answer contract", () => {
it("enforces leakage guard in direct user-facing answer", () => {
const units = [buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-1", type: "broken_chain_segment", defect: "failed_edge:payment_to_settlement", account: "60" })];
const output = composeCase("Покажи проблему по расчетам.", buildRetrieval(units));
expect(output.assistant_reply).not.toMatch(
/graph_|domain_scope|relation_patterns|route|profile|hybrid_store_plus_live|store_canonical|semantic_profile|lifecycle_defect_type/i
);
});
it("keeps narrative mechanism-first and avoids entity-list direct answer", () => {
const units = [buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-1", type: "broken_chain_segment", defect: "failed_edge:payment_to_settlement", account: "60" })];
const output = composeCase("Проверь по 60 счету, где разрыв.", buildRetrieval(units));
const brokenSection = extractSection(output.assistant_reply, "Что сломано");
expect(brokenSection).toMatch(/не подтвержден|разрыв|зависл|закрыти/i);
expect(brokenSection).not.toMatch(/^\s*-\s*(Document|Record|Entity)\b/i);
});
it("does not expose route/profile explanation in user-facing text", () => {
const units = [buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-1", type: "document_conflict", defect: "posting_mismatch", account: "60" })];
const output = composeCase("Где конфликт документа и проводки?", buildRetrieval(units));
expect(output.assistant_reply).not.toMatch(/route|profile|semantic|domain_scope|relation_patterns|typed_domain_path/i);
});
it("collapses duplicate problem lines for the same mechanism", () => {
const units = [
buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-1", type: "broken_chain_segment", defect: "failed_edge:payment_to_settlement", account: "60" }),
buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-2", type: "unresolved_settlement_cluster", defect: "payment_to_settlement", account: "60" })
];
const output = composeCase("Проверь хвост по расчетам.", buildRetrieval(units));
const brokenSection = extractSection(output.assistant_reply, "Что сломано");
const bulletLines = brokenSection
.split(/\r?\n/g)
.map((line) => line.trim())
.filter((line) => line.startsWith("- "));
expect(bulletLines.length).toBe(1);
});
it("shows explicit limitation when period is missing", () => {
const units = [buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-1", type: "lifecycle_anomaly_node", defect: "missing_expected_transition", account: "97", lifecycleDomain: "deferred_expense" })];
const output = composeCase("Проверь по 97 счету зависание списания.", buildRetrieval(units));
const limitationsSection = extractSection(output.assistant_reply, "Ограничения");
expect(limitationsSection).toMatch(/период/i);
});
it("returns short accountant-readable answers for P0 domains without technical dump", () => {
const cases: Array<{
message: string;
retrieval: UnifiedRetrievalResult;
domainHint: RegExp;
}> = [
{
message: "Проверь хвосты по расчетам 60/62.",
retrieval: buildRetrieval([
buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-60", type: "broken_chain_segment", defect: "failed_edge:payment_to_settlement", account: "60" })
]),
domainHint: /расчет|оплат|закрыти/i
},
{
message: "Проверь НДС-цепочку по документу.",
retrieval: buildRetrieval([
buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-vat", type: "cross_branch_inconsistency_cluster", defect: "invoice_linked", account: "68", lifecycleDomain: "vat_flow" })
]),
domainHint: /ндс|регистр|книг/i
},
{
message: "Проверь закрытие месяца и затраты 20-44.",
retrieval: buildRetrieval([
buildProblemUnit({ id: "pu-close", type: "period_risk_cluster", defect: "close_operation_runs", account: "20", lifecycleDomain: "period_close" })
]),
domainHint: /закрыти|месяц|затрат/i
}
];
for (const testCase of cases) {
const output = composeCase(testCase.message, testCase.retrieval);
expect(output.assistant_reply).toMatch(testCase.domainHint);
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("Коротко:");
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("Что сломано:");
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("Почему это похоже на проблему:");
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("На чем это основано:");
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("Что проверить первым:");
expect(output.assistant_reply).toContain("Ограничения:");
expect(output.assistant_reply.length).toBeLessThan(1800);
expect(output.assistant_reply).not.toMatch(/graph_|domain_scope|relation_patterns|semantic_profile|route|profile/i);
}
});
});